Results

Snapshot of results

We have a colourful new pamphlet explaining some of the key results from our project: click the image below to download, and feel free to distribute.

Research results brochure

First two research papers now free to download

Our first two research papers have been accepted for publication in the leading open access journal Information Research. You can download them in full text from the links below.

  • Available - but not accessible? Investigating publisher e-lending licensing practices

  • This paper analyses the results of the two focused studies, and reports significant intra- and cross-jurisdictional differences that surprised even the aggregators who contributed data..!

  • What can 100,000 books tell us about the international public library e-lending landscape?

  • This paper analyses the large-scale study, drawing on almost 100,000 books across five countries. We find that price and license differences across countries are largely attributable to 'Big 5' publishers, and that prices are largely independent of title age (unless the title is in the public domain) or the rights libraries obtain in exchange. Licence terms are not affected by age either, meaning that the most restrictive terms are often applied to older, less demanded books. We conclude that, by setting terms independent of titles’ value to libraries, publishers may discourage libraries from adding older and less-demanded books to their collections.

IFLA keynote

The elending project's leader A/Professor Rebecca Giblin delivered a keynote address at the 2018 IFLA World Library and Information Congress with some key results from the project. Watch it below:

APLIC talk

A more detailed talk from Rebecca Giblin explaining key findings from the two Focused studies (as delivered at the Asia Pacific Library and Information Conference in 2018) is also available:

>

We will upload our formal written papers detailing the research findings as soon as the peer review process permits.

Using the interactive dashboards

How to use

Visually query the interactive dashboards by simply clicking or sliding characteristics of interest. Here's a good first query to wet your feet with: go to the Focused Australian Study via the link at the top of the page, then click ‘Hachette’ in the Publisher chart. You'll see the whole dashboard immediately update to show you how availability of Hachette titles on each of the five platforms (and how that compares to availability in physical form).

You can query by as many characteristics as you like. Just make sure that when you want to start afresh, you click the 'Reset all filters' button to be sure you're you’re only limiting your query in the way you intend.

The 'reset all filters' button

For more details on using the dashboards, see the video tutorials below. There's one for the Focused Studies, and a separate one for the Large-scale study.

Video tutorial: Using the interactive dashboards for the focused studies

>

Video tutorial: Using the interactive dashboards for the Large-scale study

>

Downloading the datasets

You can download the whole dataset, or a selected part, by clicking one of the buttons to the right of the data table at the bottom of each dashboard as shown in the image below.

Showing how to download the datasets

Using (and misusing) these data

Please jump in and use these dashboards and the public datasets we have released - we made them for you! However, please do not take the work out of its research context and use it for other purposes (such as deciding whether to enter into a contract with a particular aggregator). That would be a really bad idea, not least because the landscape has no doubt changed significantly since we collected these data. We also strongly urge against any attempt to de-pseudonymise the aggregators who have provided this data to us in good faith in order to assist the research team and library communities to better understand the e-lending landscape.

What to do if you find something weird or cool

If you find results of particular interest we’d love to hear from you - please get in touch or tweet to @rgibli with the hashtag #elendingproject.

ABOUT THE PROJECT

This work is part of an Australian Research Council Linkage Project (LP160100387) led by Associate Professor Rebecca Giblin (Monash University). The other Chief Investigators are Professor Kimberlee Weatherall (University of Sydney), Professor Julian Thomas (RMIT) and Dr François Petitjean. (Monash University). Our research team has also included postdoctoral fellows Dr Jenny Kennedy (RMIT) and Dr Charlotte Pelletier (Monash University), Master’s student in Data Science Woratana Ngarmtrakulchol, and research assistants Dan Gilbert, Jacob Flynn and Emily van der Nagel.

Rebecca Francois Kim Julian
Jenny Charlotte
Perth Dan Jacob Emily

The Linkage Project is supported by formal partnerships with:

  • National and State Libraries Australasia (NSLA)
  • Australian Library and Information Association (ALIA)
  • State Library of Western Australia
  • State Library of South Australia
  • State Library of NSW
  • Yarra Plenty Regional Library Service
  • Gold Coast City Council
  • Brisbane City Council

Further invaluable international cooperation has been contributed by:

  • Vancouver Public Library (Canada)
  • St Mary’s County Library (as part of the Maryland Digital Library consortium) (US)
  • Auckland Libraries (NZ)
  • Hampshire Libraries (UK)

We thank all our partners for their contributions of expertise, time and other resources, and to aggregators Overdrive, Baker & Taylor, Bibliotheca, Wheelers and Bolinda for their cooperation and support.

About the dashboards

These interactive dashboards were produced by Woratana Ngarmtrakulchol (aka 'Perth') under the supervision of Associate Professor Rebecca Giblin and Dr François Petitjean. The tools used were D3.js, Crossfilter.js, DC.js, Bootstrap, and FontAwesome. The dashboard project was completed in 2019.